To start with, it is important to underline these two games have many similarities, as they both are derived, or evolved from, or are a distillation from the original RuneQuest system, specifically the 2nd and 3rd edition. Also, for the sake of this comparison, I am bundling Mythras and its free-to-download primer Mythras Imperative together, but I am also mentioning some useful supplements. So before mentioning the differences, let's point out their similarities.
Similarities:
- Multi-genre
- Several power levels for starting characters
- At least 7 characteristics on a 3-18 range (for normal humans)
- List of skills with scores expressed in percentages
- Characteristics influence base skill %
- 1D100 "roll-under" basic roll
- At least 4 degrees of success/failure
- Professions/Careers
- Skills can be trained
- Attack and defence rolls in combat
- Damage modifier, location hit points, power points, fate/luck points
- Different kinds of weapon damage (crushing, impaling, slashing...)
- List of equipment: from two-handed axes to bulletproof vests
- Damage absorbing armour
- Characters advance through experience
- At least 5 different magic/powers systems
- Rules for aging
- Rules for vehicles
- Rules for passions
- Bestiary included
- Free-to-download scenarios and quickstart
So, having looked at their long list of similarities, let's have a look at their main differences:
There are obviously many more differences, but they are pretty minor, so I have focused on the most relevant ones. If you have questions or comments, please let me know below! For further details, you can read my reviews of Mythras and Basic Roleplaying.
Differences:
| Mythras + Mythras Imperative | Basic Roleplaying (BRP) | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | MythrasThey cover a limited amount of genres, but the game has a wide range of supplements available (Destined, Luther Arkwright, Worlds United, After the Vampire Wars, etc.) covering many genres in more detail. | Basic RoleplayingIt covers a wide range of genres, including guidelines on what rules to choose for emulating many genres. More detail can be found in games like Superworld, Call of Cthulhu and supplements like The Magic Book. |
| Character creation | MythrasBy assigning points to skills based on culture, career and personal interests. Social class table, family, enemies and allies, and fantasy background events. | Basic RoleplayingBy assigning points to skills based on personality type, profession and personal interests. Wealth level. Optional cultural bonuses. Optional personality traits and distinctive features. |
| Characteristic rolls | MythrasThey are standard skills starting at characteristic + characteristic): Brawn, Endurance, Evade, Willpower… so characteristics see little use after character creation. | Basic RoleplayingCharacteristics can be rolled as generic skills: STRx5, CONx5, DEXx5, INTx5, etc. Education is an optional characteristic. |
| Charisma | MythrasFacilitates skill advancement. Limits the amount of spirits you can bind if using the animism magic system. | Basic RoleplayingIt only influences social skills and the CHAx5 roll. |
| Passions | MythrasAutomatic augment to a fitting skill by +1/5 of the Passion %. | Basic RoleplayingAugment of up to +50% or subtract -10% (or suffer despair) to a fitting skill depending on the roll's result. |
| Sanity | MythrasRules for sanity and madness are only included in the Mythras Companion and the White Death scenario. | Basic RoleplayingIncludes sanity rules. Detailed rules for madness are in Call of Cthulhu. |
| Status/Wealth | MythrasSocial class, plus equipment cost specified in coins. | Basic RoleplayingStatus skill and Wealth determine what equipment can be purchased. You roll Status to acquire items above your Wealth level. |
| Degrees of success | Mythras4 | Basic Roleplaying5 |
| Skills | MythrasProfessional skills and Standard skills. Few skills but more generic: Athletics, Stealth, Perception… | Basic RoleplayingMany specific skills: Jump, Climb, Hide, Stealth, Spot, Listen… |
| Opposed rolls | MythrasThe best level of success wins. In case of same level of success, the highest roll wins. | Basic Roleplaying3 options: the best level of success wins. In case of same level of success, the highest roll wins. Opposed skill subtraction, or one roll on the Resistance table. |
| Difficulty modifiers | Mythras6 levels from "Very Easy" (double the skill) to "Herculean" (1/5 skill). Alternatively, straight modifiers such as +40% for "Very Easy". | Basic RoleplayingDouble skill value for "Easy" rolls or half skill value for "Difficult" rolls. |
| Luck/Fate points | MythrasLuck points allow rerolls, reading rolls backwards, avoiding major wounds or an extra action point. | Basic RoleplayingFate points allow rerolls. POWx5 is used to determine if a PC gets lucky. |
| Actions in combat | MythrasDetermined by action points (usually 2-3). DEX and INT determine action points. Initiative roll determines order of action. Alternatively: everyone gets 2 action points. | Basic Roleplaying1 Action or Attack per turn plus any number of parries or dodges. Characters act in Dexterity (DEX) order. |
| Combat skills | MythrasCombat style skill encompasses several weapons and includes a trait. | Basic RoleplayingIndependent skills for weapon classes, such as axe, polearm, club, rifle, shotgun, etc. |
| Combat effects on top of damage | MythrasAttacks or defences scoring a success level higher than the opponent's inflict a special effect (32 to pick): Bypass Armour, Disarm, Choose Location, Impale, Rapid Reload, Blind Opponent, etc. | Basic RoleplayingUnparried critical attacks cause maximum damage and ignore armour. Special attacks inflict an additional effect for slashing, crushing, entangling, or impaling weapons. Attacks to aim or to subdue have a Difficult mod. |
| Parrying | MythrasEvery parry or dodge requires spending 1 action point. | Basic RoleplayingEvery parry after the first has a cumulative -30% modifier. |
| Dodging | MythrasEvading leaves you prone (except if you have a particular trait). | Basic RoleplayingDodging does not leave you prone. |
| Passive parry | MythrasWeapons can be used to passively protect some locations. | Basic RoleplayingOnly shields can passively protect some locations, and only projectiles. |
| Hit points | MythrasOnly location hit points. You die when one of your locations suffers as much damage as twice or equal its hit points. | Basic RoleplayingTotal hit points and optional location hit points. You die when your total hit points reach 0, so you can die from accumulated wounds. |
| Fatigue | MythrasFatigue is counted in levels (Winded, Tired, Wearied...). | Basic RoleplayingFatigue is an optional rule counted in Fatigue points. |
| Formation combat | MythrasWhen combatants have the appropriate trait, they substract an action point from their adversaries. | Basic Roleplaying- |
| Mass combat | MythrasRules are in the supplement Ships & Shieldwalls. These rules are based on units fighting each other. | Basic RoleplayingAbstracted through opposed Strategy rolls, and/or played as small engagements at the appropriate level, with Luck rolls determining additional damage due to the battle chaos. |
| Chases | MythrasRules are included in the Mythras Companion. You can also use the rules for crafting items. | Basic RoleplayingOpposed rolls move participants along a range track. Vehicular chases include manoeuvers. |
| Social combat | MythrasRules are included in the Mythras Companion. You can also use the rules for crafting items. | Basic Roleplaying- |
| Training | MythrasRequires spending experience points and studying with a teacher. | Basic RoleplayingRequires studying with a teacher or on your own. |
| Bestiary | MythrasThe corebook includes 60 fantasy creatures/animals (centaurs, elves, dwarves, minotaurs, halflings, iqari, etc.); Mythras Imperative adds a xenomorphic alien. | Basic RoleplayingIncludes 30 animals, 18 fantasy creatures (centaurs, elves, dwarves....), 7 summoned creatures (angel, water elemental...), 6 science fiction creatures (aliens, robots), and 23 NPCs from different genres (pirate, police officer, supervillain...) |
| Character progression | MythrasAfter an adventure you get an amount of experience points you can spend in experience rolls to increase any skill. If you succeed in these rolls, you gain 1D4+1 points in the skill, and only 1 if you fail. You must spend points if you want new spells or powers. | Basic RoleplayingAfter an adventure you get experience rolls in all rolls successfully used. If you succeed in the experience roll, you gain between 1D6 and 1D10 (or just 3) points in that skill. New spells and powers are acquired by spending time and resources. |
| Magic systems | MythrasFolk magic (low power spells, only 1 skill needed), theism (miracles from the gods), animism (shamans making fetishes and binding spirits), sorcery, and mysticism (self-enhancing talents a la warrior monks). Mythras Imperative includes some superpowers, but the game Destined includes more. Psionic powers in the Luther Arkwright book. | Basic RoleplayingMagic (spells from several sources), sorcery (magic from grimoires), psychic powers, mutations, and superpowers. The Magic Book supplement includes spirit magic, divine magic and sorcery from RuneQuest 3rd ed. |
| Spirit combat | MythrasIncludes attacks and parries, and its own special effects. | Basic RoleplayingPsychic combat is a series of opposed rolls. |
| Resisting magic | MythrasOpposed roll between the target's Endurance, Willpower or Evade vs the caster's appropriate magic skill roll. | Basic RoleplayingPOW vs POW opposed roll. |
| Cults/Guilds | MythrasGuidelines for creating them and 3 samples. | Basic Roleplaying- |
| Content under the ORC license | MythrasOnly the rules in Mythras Imperative, which includes some not in the corebook: simplified PC creation, 31 careers, power levels, passions, combat with 32 special effects, weapons and firearms, vehicle rules with 13 samples and rules to create your own, 2 magic systems ("Magic" with 23 spells and 17 superpowers), 10 creatures and 21 abilities to create your own. | Basic RoleplayingThe whole book. |
There are obviously many more differences, but they are pretty minor, so I have focused on the most relevant ones. If you have questions or comments, please let me know below! For further details, you can read my reviews of Mythras and Basic Roleplaying.
Conclusions
It is difficult to judge which one is the best, as that will depend on your intended use and your personal taste. I prefer the magic systems in Mythras, as for example superpowers are always on and you only spend power points to increase their effect. I also love the social combat rules. On the other hand, Basic Roleplaying includes rules for chases, while the rules for that in the Mythras Companion look too complicated to me. The thing with some of the subsystems in Mythras (like chases, spirit combat and social combat) is that they all include special effects. One of the pros is that they add a lot of variety and make scenes narrate themselves. However, one of the cons is that they can induce some analysis-paralysis, and mastering when to use each of them is an art that takes time, so f.ex. you cannot introduce a social combat scene all of a sudden in a campaign and expect your players to play with these rules well right off the bat.
The key point is if you like the crunchier, more tactical combat Mythras offers (with all its special effects), or if you prefer the simplicity of combat in Basic Roleplaying. If your players love choosing the best special effect during combats, this system shines. But if they are easily overwhelmed by options, or your campaign does not focus on combat, it becomes too much. At any rate, the best thing is, both systems are similar enough that you can import all the rules you like to your favourite one or mix and match as you please. Play them both!
But, what if you want to publish your own RPG or scenario based on either of these rulesets thanks to the ORC License? Then you need to decide which rules most fit your game or scenario. Basic Roleplaying offers more rules to choose from (the whole book), but maybe you prefer some of the rules included in Mythras Imperative instead. It looks like it would be possible to use both ORC licenses in the same product, so you could use rules from both in one publication, but I am not a lawyer, and I do not know if that could cause some kind of trouble. I also have not managed to find any clear answers on the Internet. If you are thinking of creating your own D100 game, you may want to look at this list of D100 settings. Also, if you want to check out any of these rulesets for free, download Mythras Imperative and the Basic Roleplaying Quickstart.
The Basic Roleplaying Quickstart and the Mythras Imperative, both free to download.
So what is your favourite multi-genre D100 ruleset? Which rules are your favourites from both systems? I honestly want both to thrive, because I love both. Let me know your opinion in the comments below!
